Augmentin vs Amoxicillin: Which should you be prescribed?

Amoxicillin and Augmentin are both prescription antibiotics used to treat bacterial infections, but they aren’t interchangeable for every situation. Doctors typically prescribe Augmentin in cases where amoxicillin alone may not be effective—especially for infections likely to involve resistant bacteria or when previous treatment has failed. Choosing between these medications depends on the type of infection, patient history, and risk of antibiotic resistance.

What Are Amoxicillin and Augmentin?

Amoxicillin is a widely used penicillin-type antibiotic effective against many common infections. Augmentin combines amoxicillin with clavulanic acid, which blocks bacterial enzymes called beta-lactamases that can make bacteria resistant to amoxicillin alone. This addition gives Augmentin broader coverage, especially against resistant strains.

How Do Doctors Decide Which One to Prescribe?

Doctors select amoxicillin or Augmentin based on the likely bacterial cause. For example, simple infections without suspected resistance usually get amoxicillin. For conditions like sinusitis, bronchitis, UTI, or ear infections, Augmentin is used when infection may involve resistant bacteria or has failed to improve with amoxicillin. Augmentin is also a first-line choice for acute bacterial rhinosinusitis and complicated skin/dental infections.

When Is Amoxicillin Enough?

Amoxicillin is preferred for mild, uncomplicated infections, such as strep throat, simple UTIs, and basic respiratory infections. It is usually chosen when beta-lactamase production isn’t expected, meaning resistance is less likely. Amoxicillin is better tolerated and causes fewer side effects, making it especially suitable for children and those sensitive to GI problems.

When Is Augmentin the Better Option?

Augmentin is prescribed for recurrent or resistant infections and polymicrobial conditions like dental abscesses or complicated sinus infections. When amoxicillin alone has failed, Augmentin’s clavulanate component helps overcome resistance. Clinical trials have shown Augmentin is more effective against infections involving bacteria that resist regular penicillins, such as Staphylococcus aureus in skin infections.

Special Considerations

Before prescribing amoxicillin or Augmentin, healthcare providers must consider important individual factors that can affect both effectiveness and safety. These include patient age, pregnancy status, drug allergies, and the potential for interactions with other medications. Each of these considerations influences which antibiotic is most appropriate and how it should be used in specific populations.

• Pediatrics: Both drugs are commonly used, but dosing differs for children based on infection severity.
• Pregnancy: Both medications are relatively safe, though Augmentin should be used only when necessary during pregnancy due to rare risks (like necrotizing enterocolitis with preterm membrane rupture).
• Allergy: Both are in the penicillin class; any history of penicillin allergy is a contraindication.
• Kidney Problems: Patients with severe renal impairment may require a dose reduction of amoxicillin.
• Drug Interactions: Augmentin and amoxicillin can interact with anticoagulants, oral contraceptives, and certain gout medications, requiring monitoring and possible dose adjustment.

Related questions

• What are the best antibiotics for a tooth infection?
• Can you drink alcohol with amoxicillin?
• Does amoxicillin expire? Is it safe to take after expiration?

Side Effects: Which Is Better Tolerated?

Augmentin is more likely to cause gastrointestinal upset, such as diarrhea or nausea, due to the clavulanic acid. Amoxicillin generally causes fewer side effects and is better tolerated, particularly in children. Side effects like rash, allergic reactions, Clostridioides difficile colitis, and rarely, liver problems, can occur with both. To minimize GI side effects, both medicines can be taken with food.

Summary Table: Augmentin vs Amoxicillin

What If Neither Option Is Right for You?

Doctors may recommend alternatives when there’s a penicillin allergy or if treatment fails. Common options include:

• Cephalexin (Keflex) – certain skin infections
• Azithromycin (Zithromax) – respiratory or sinus infections; penicillin allergy choice
• Clindamycin – resistant or anaerobic infections
• Doxycycline – acne, respiratory infections, Lyme disease
• Nitrofurantoin or Bactrim – uncomplicated UTIs (non-penicillin class)

Always consult a healthcare provider before starting or changing antibiotics, or assuming an alternative is appropriate. The right choice depends on the infection’s cause, patient history, and risk factors.

Read next

See also:

Related medical questions

• Does amoxicillin help with tooth infection and pain?
• What's the difference between amoxicillin and penicillin?
• What happens if antibiotics don’t work for UTI?
• What are the best antibiotics for pneumonia?
• If I am allergic to penicillin, is it safe to use amoxicillin?
• What medications can affect your taste or smell?
• Amoxicillin for ear infection: Take how many times a day?
• What's the normal daily dose of amoxicillin 500mg for chest infections?
• Are there any foods I should avoid while taking amoxicillin?
• Can you safely consume alcohol while taking amoxicillin?
• If people are allergic to amoxicillin can they take cephalexin?
• How often should I take amoxicillin for a sinus infection?
• Can amoxicillin be used to treat a bacterial vaginitis infection?
• What is the recommended dosage of amoxicillin for a 14 year old child?
• Amoxicillin - does it have sulfa or penicillin in it?
• Can penicillin treat chlamydia?
• If I can not take penicillin, is amoxicillin the same or do I need to avoid it?
• Can you take antibiotics while pregnant?
• How do language barriers affect safe medication use?
• Can you drink alcohol while taking Augmentin?
• What is the best antibiotic to treat a sinus infection?

Drug information

• Amoxicillin (368 reviews)
• Augmentin (451 reviews)

Related support groups

• Amoxicillin (203 questions, 306 members)
• Augmentin (32 questions, 77 members)

Medical Disclaimer