Comparing Prescription Opioids to Over-the-Counter Pain Relief

Research has found opioids provide no significant advantage over OTC medications for most pain conditions, while carrying substantially higher risks of addiction, constipation, and respiratory depression. This guide compares prescription opioids (oxycodone and hydrocodone) against over-the-counter analgesics (acetaminophen, ibuprofen, and naproxen) for pain management across various conditions.

Understanding that different types of pain, whether inflammatory (such as that caused by rheumatoid arthritis), mechanical (like muscle strains), neuropathic, or post-surgical, require tailored treatment approaches is crucial for effective pain management.

Latest Research: Opioids vs OTC Medications

A 2023 Lancet meta-analysis demonstrated that IV acetaminophen (paracetamol) or IV or IM NSAIDs showed no significant difference in pain relief compared to IV opioids in 5006 patients presenting to the ED with a diverse range of pain conditions, with dramatically better safety profiles.

• This research showed that when properly dosed, patients receiving NSAIDs required fewer additional pain medications for breakthrough pain, while opioid use resulted in higher rates of side effects.
• The authors concluded that NSAIDs were the preferred analgesic choice, with IV paracetamol an effective alternative option.

For chronic non-cancer pain, a meta-analysis of 46 studies found no significant difference in pain relief between opioids and other treatments (NSAIDs, physical therapy, psychotherapy). The research does not support opioids as preferred treatment, instead recommending combination approaches like physical therapy plus NSAIDs. This challenges the misconception that opioids are the most effective for pain relief for chronic conditions, because addiction and withdrawal risks outweigh their benefits.

OTC Pain Relievers: First-Line Treatment for All Types of Pain

NSAIDs (Anti-Inflammatory):

• Ibuprofen (OTC dose): 200-400 mg every 6 to 8 hours (maximum 1,200 mg daily)
• Ibuprofen (prescription dose): 600-800 mg every 6-8 hours (maximum 3,200 mg daily)
• Naproxen: 220-440 mg every 8-12 hours
• Diclofenac gel: Topical application for localized pain.

Acetaminophen:

• Adult dose: 325 mg to 1 g orally every 4 to 6 hours
• Maximum: 3,000 to 4,000 mg daily for adults
• Can combine with NSAIDs for additive effect
• Safe for most patients including those with cardiovascular concerns.

Combination Therapy:

• Clinical trials show ibuprofen 400 mg + acetaminophen 1,000 mg provides superior pain relief compared to either medication alone or many prescription opioids.

Oxycodone vs Hydrocodone: Direct Comparison

Multiple studies show oxycodone and hydrocodone provide equivalent pain relief for both cancer-related and acute severe pain (such as fractures), and 5 mg oxycodone = 5 mg hydrocodone. Side effects like nausea, vomiting, and drowsiness are similar between both medications, but hydrocodone causes significantly more constipation (21% vs 0% in clinical trials).

Oxycodone was found to be more likely to be abused than oral morphine and hydrocodone in a review of nine good quality clinical studies.

Hydrocodone Advantages:

• Lower abuse potential compared to oxycodone
• Cost-effective generic combinations widely available
• Cough suppressant properties - useful for respiratory conditions
• Combination formulations (Norco, Vicodin) commonly prescribed.

Oxycodone Advantages:

• Lower constipation rates (0% vs 21% in clinical trials)
• Extended-release options available (OxyContin)
• Pure formulations without acetaminophen (safer for liver)
• Better studied in various pain conditions.

Side Effect Profiles

Common Side Effects (Both):

• Nausea and vomiting
• Drowsiness and dizziness
• Respiratory depression risk
• Potential for dependency.

Hydrocodone-Specific:

• Higher constipation incidence (21% of patients)
• Drug interactions with acetaminophen combinations.

Oxycodone-Specific:

• Higher euphoric effects (increased abuse risk)
• More pronounced respiratory depression at higher doses.

See also: Drugs.com Compare Tool - Oxycodone vs Hydrocodone

Pain Type-Specific Treatment Approaches

Inflammatory Pain (Arthritis, Autoimmune Conditions)

Inflammatory pain requires addressing the underlying autoimmune process rather than just treating symptoms, making disease-modifying medications the cornerstone of effective management. Examples of conditions that cause inflammatory pain include rheumatoid arthritis and autoimmune conditions.

First-Line Treatment:

• Disease-modifying therapy (DMARDs for RA, biologics)
• NSAIDs for symptom relief - meloxicam, celecoxib
• Corticosteroids for acute flares (short-term only).

Opioid Considerations:

• Poor effectiveness - inflammatory pain responds poorly to opioids
• Drug interactions with disease-modifying medications
• JAK inhibitors emerging as superior pain option for inflammatory conditions.

When opioids needed: Prefer hydrocodone (lower abuse risk for chronic conditions).

Related questions

• How long does oxycodone stay in your system?
• Which drugs cause opioid-induced constipation?
• Tramadol vs. Oxycodone: What are the key differences?

Mechanical/Injury Pain (Strains, Fractures, Post-Surgical)

For mechanical pain caused by tissue damage or inflammation from injury, anti-inflammatory medications combined with activity modification typically provide the most effective relief. Examples of mechanical pain include muscle strains, herniated discs, fractures, and post-operative pain.

First-Line Treatment:

• NSAIDs + acetaminophen combination most effective
• Ice/heat therapy and activity modification
• Physical therapy within 2 weeks if no improvement.

Opioid Guidelines:

• Maximum 7 days for acute injuries (2022 CDC guidelines)
• Lowest effective dose
• Reassess after 72 hours.

When opioids needed: Prefer oxycodone (lower constipation risk for short-term use).

Neuropathic Pain (Nerve Damage)

Neuropathic pain results from damaged or malfunctioning nerves and responds poorly to traditional pain medications, requiring specialized treatments that target nerve signaling pathways. Examples include diabetic neuropathy, post-herpetic neuralgia, or sciatica.

Specialized Treatment:

• Gabapentin or pregabalin (first-line)
• Tricyclic antidepressants (amitriptyline)
• Topical agents (capsaicin, lidocaine).

Opioid Role: Generally ineffective for neuropathic pain; other medications much more successful.

When Are Opioids Appropriate?

Short-term opioid therapy may be considered for:

• Severe acute pain (fractures, post-surgical) when OTC insufficient
• Cancer-related pain (palliative care)
• End-of-life care (comfort measures)
• Acute flares of chronic conditions during treatment optimization.

2022 CDC Opioid Guidelines

• Avoid opioids for most chronic non-cancer pain
• Maximum 7 days for acute pain conditions
• Lowest effective dose always
• Frequent reassessment required
• Multimodal approach preferred (combining different treatment types).

Safety Considerations and Red Flags

Opioid Risk Factors

Patients at higher risk for opioid abuse or side effects include those with:

• History of substance abuse
• Mental health conditions
• Concurrent sedating medications
• Sleep apnea or respiratory conditions
• Age over 65.

Choosing Between Oxycodone and Hydrocodone

If opioids are truly necessary choose hydrocodone for:

• Chronic conditions (lower abuse risk)
• Patients with constipation concerns who need combination products
• Cost-sensitive situations (generics widely available)
• Respiratory symptoms (cough suppressant benefit).

Choose oxycodone for:

• Acute, short-term pain (lower constipation risk)
• Patients avoiding acetaminophen (liver concerns)
• Need for extended-release (severe, continuous pain)
• Post-surgical pain (well-studied in this setting).

Formulations

Because opioids usually work better in combination with other analgesics, both oxycodone and hydrocodone are available formulated with other ingredients such as acetaminophen or ibuprofen.

Oxycodone is available in an immediate and controlled-release forms, and in combination with acetaminophen, aspirin, and ibuprofen. A naloxone combination product was available but this has recently been discontinued. Oxycontin, the controlled-release form, was reformulated by the manufacturer in 2010 in an attempt to curb epidemic levels of abuse.

Hydrocodone intended for pain relief is available as abuse-deterrent controlled-release capsules (Hysingla ER, Zohydro ER) and in combination with acetaminophen or ibuprofen.

Are there any differences in the way oxycodone and hydrocodone work in the body?

Structurally, oxycodone (molecular formula C18H21NO4) and hydrocodone (molecular formula C18H21NO3) are very similar, the difference in their structure comes down to one extra oxygen atom on Oxycodone.

Oxycodone is semi-synthetic and is synthesized from thebaine (an opium alkaloid) and will only relieve pain, not cough.

Hydrocodone is also semi-synthetic but derived from codeine, and while more potent than codeine, still retains cough suppressant properties. It is more commonly found in combination with other nonopioid analgesics (for example acetaminophen), although abuse-deterrent formulations of just hydrocodone are available.

Emerging Alternatives

• Topical NSAIDs - Targeted relief, fewer systemic effects
• Cannabinoids - Limited evidence but growing research
• Neuromodulation - Spinal cord stimulation for chronic conditions
• Regenerative medicine - PRP, stem cell therapies (experimental).

Key Takeaways

For most pain conditions, properly dosed OTC medications provide equivalent pain relief to prescription opioids with dramatically better safety profiles and lower costs.

The most effective approach matches the medication to the type of pain. Inflammatory pain needs anti-inflammatories, neuropathic pain needs specialized medications, and mechanical pain often responds well to OTC combinations.

When prescription pain medication is truly necessary, hydrocodone offers lower abuse risk for chronic conditions while oxycodone provides lower constipation risk for short-term use.

Start with the safest effective option (usually OTC combinations), escalate gradually based on evidence, and always include non-medication approaches for optimal pain management.

References

• Oxycodone, https://www.drugs.com/pro/oxycodone.html
• Hydrocodone, https://www.drugs.com/hydrocodone.html
• Schmidt-Hansen M, Bennett MI, Arnold S, Bromham N, Hilgart JS. Oxycodone for cancer-related pain. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2015, Issue 2. Art. No.: CD003870. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD003870.pub5.
• Rodriguez RF, Castillo JM, Castillo MP et al. Hydrocodone/acetaminophen and tramadol chlorhydrate combination tablets for the management of chronic cancer pain: a double-blind comparative trial. Clin J Pain. 2008 Jan;24(1):1-4. doi: 10.1097/AJP.0b013e318156ca4d.
• Marco, C. A., Plewa, M. C., Buderer, N., Black, C. and Roberts, A. (2005), Comparison of Oxycodone and Hydrocodone for the Treatment of Acute Pain Associated with Fractures: A Double-blind, Randomized, Controlled Trial. Academic Emergency Medicine, 12: 282–288. doi: 10.1197/j.aem.2004.12.005, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1197/j.aem.2004.12.005/epdf
• Reinecke H, Weber C, Lange K, Simon M, Stein C, Sorgatz H. Analgesic efficacy of opioids in chronic pain: recent meta-analyses. British Journal of Pharmacology. 2015;172(2):324-333. doi:10.1111/bph.12634.
• Wightman R , Perrone J , Portelli I , Nelson L. Likeability and abuse liability of commonly prescribed opioids. Journal of Medical Toxicology: Official Journal of the American College of Medical Toxicology [2012, 8(4):335-40. PMID:22992943 PMCID:PMC3550270
• Injury Prevention & Control: Prescription Drug Overdose. Centers For Disease Control and Prevention. 01/2016 - http://www.cdc.gov/drugoverdose/
• Lyford J. Reformulated OxyContin reduces abuse but many addicts have switched to heroin. The Pharmaceutical Journal 16 MAR 2015 www.pharmaceutical-journal.com/news-and-analysis/news/reformulated-oxycontin-reduces-abuse-but-many-addicts-have-switched-to-heroin/20068119.article
• Can the U.S. Win the War On Opioids? 02/2016 blog.drugs.com/2016/02/can-the-u-s-win-the-war-on-opioids/
• Hydrocodone. National Center for Biotechnology Information. PubChem Compound Database; CID=5284569, https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/5284569
• Oxycodone. National Center for Biotechnology Information. PubChem Compound Database; CID=5284603, https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/compound/5284603
• Reinecke H, Weber C, Lange K, Simon M, Stein C, Sorgatz H. Analgesic efficacy of opioids in chronic pain: recent meta-analyses. Br J Pharmacol. 2015 Jan;172(2):324-33. doi: 10.1111/bph.12634. Epub 2014 Jul 1. PMID: 24640991; PMCID: PMC4292950. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24640991/
• Marco CA, Plewa MC, Buderer N, Black C, Roberts A. Comparison of oxycodone and hydrocodone for the treatment of acute pain associated with fractures: a double-blind, randomized, controlled trial. Acad Emerg Med. 2005 Apr;12(4):282-8. doi: 10.1197/j.aem.2004.12.005. PMID: 15805317. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15805317/
• Wightman R, Perrone J, Portelli I, Nelson L. Likeability and abuse liability of commonly prescribed opioids. J Med Toxicol. 2012 Dec;8(4):335-40. doi: 10.1007/s13181-012-0263-x. PMID: 22992943; PMCID: PMC3550270. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3550270/

Read next

See also:

Related medical questions

• How long does opioid withdrawal last?
• Which painkiller should you use?
• What are the withdrawal symptoms of oxycodone?
• What is Hydrochloride or HCL in a drugname?
• How addictive is OxyContin (oxycodone)?
• Treating Opioid Overdose with Naloxone
• How do I use opioid pain medications safely?
• Norco vs Vicodin - How do they compare?
• How long does Norco stay in your system?
• How do I treat back pain without using opioids?

Drug information

• Oxycodone (1,147 reviews)
• Hydrocodone (201 reviews)
• Norco (368 reviews)
• OxyContin (294 reviews)
• Vicodin (146 reviews)

Related support groups

• Oxycodone (269 questions, 2,630 members)
• Hydrocodone (203 questions, 1,475 members)
• Norco (98 questions, 1,161 members)
• OxyContin (73 questions, 1,362 members)
• Vicodin (72 questions, 865 members)
• Pain (2,289 questions, 11,957 members)
• Cancer (198 questions, 645 members)
• Chronic Pain (303 questions, 3,369 members)

Medical Disclaimer