I took Omeprazole (generic for Prilosec) for 12 years when I found that I was having some horrible side affects such as Urinary Tract Infections, Sinus Infections, bone pain, shortness of breath, nausea in the morning, etc. I slowly stopped taking the above and am now on Zantac #150 each morning an hour before my meal. I tried taking a second one since heartburn returns after 8 or 9 hours of taking the Zantac. I noticed some of the symptoms return that I had when taking the Omeprazole such as the shortness of breath. Is there a difference between the Zantac and the Omeprazole and what is the difference?
What is the difference between Zantac and Omeprazole for GERD?
Question posted by AquariusAnneCA on 23 Jan 2013
Last updated on 3 October 2018 by Halfadoctor
The information on this page reflects personal experiences shared by our community members. It is not reviewed for medical accuracy and should not replace professional medical advice.
9 Answers
Omeprazole is a proton pump inhibitor, Zantac/ranitidine is an h2 antagonist. They both do the same job, just by different mechanisms - they both decrease production of acid by the stomach.
They are used for heartburn/reflux/GERD as reducing the production of acid in the stomach helps prevent it damaging your esophagus and causing you pain when he liquid in your stomach refluxes up into your esophagus (often due to an ineffective esophageal sphincter).
They are both extremely good medications which prevent symptoms and damage to the esophagus and can be used long term without problems in most people. They can cause side effects in some people including headache, nausea and diarrhoea or constipation.
Very rarely in people who are sensitive omeprazole can cause shortness of breath due to bronchospam.
Zantac is not known to cause shortness of breath.
If you are experiencing shortness of breath it would be best to have this investigated.
Zantac is more for treating gas in your GI. Omeprazole is for GERD. Omeprazole is found to be much more powerful than Zantac of treating GERD. Apart from the side effects you mentioned above, you should check your magnesium level (blood test) since you had been taking that for 12 years. Lack of magnesium can cause muscle cramps.
Beware taking any PPI drugs ( Nexium, Omeprazole, Prevacid, & others). They can be very dangerous long term. They do get rid of the acid in your stomach, but you need acid in your stomach for proper digestion. They also get rid of the acid in your brain which you also need to "eat up" the beta amyloids which cause dementia. You need a med that will take care of the acid in your esophagus, not stomach & brain. There are many adverse side effects & problems with PPI (Proton Pump Inhibitor) drugs. I am looking for something that will take care of the acid in my esophagus & leave the acid in my stomach & brain alone. The sphincter muscle can be the cause, if it doesn't open & close properly, but how can you get it to function properly?
The reason why your lungs probably looked that way is because of the acid in your stomach coming back up your esophagus and entering into your trachea therefore into your lungs. Chronic acid reflux can cause inflammation in the lungs which is what would show up brightly lit on the scan. Reflux doesn't always cause heartburn so you may not think that you are experiencing any when you actually are.
The reason why your recent scan came back normal is because prednisone got rid of the inflammation caused by chronic acid reflux.
Go see a gastroenterologist and ask to be put on protonix. It is a proton pump inhibitor and it is well tolerated.
Also, invest in a wedge pillow. Stomach acid travels back up the esophagus at night more than any other time because of your positioning. Allowing for acid to get into your airways and cause all of the inflammation in the lungs.
Avoid eating late. 3-4 hours before your expected bedtime is a good span to have.
Well, in my case the Zantac did me no good. I am taking Nexium, in fact 2 per day. I had the TIF procedure done almost 2 years ago and they declared me a healed person. But it did not last, as soon as I came off the drugs, soon they scoped me and I had reflux up to my throat. I would suggest a good gastro doctor. Reflux or GERD is nothing to play around with, you can end up with Barrett's esophagus and this can lead to cancer. Don't want to scare you, I get tested and have have the fortune so far of no indication of Barrett's or anything., but I am stuck with the Nexium. Be sure you seek good medical advice.
Hi Papsam,
I have gone to 3 different gastro doctors and I have had the tests done and the answer is take the medication or have the surgery... I cannot take the meds due to very serious side affects and surgery is scary to me. The Zantac seems to help in that I do not get the serious heartburn like I did... so I will continue with that and when the heartburn is bothering me at nite, I will take a Zantac at nite. (only take one a day in the morning)... If I feel too badly I will definitely see a gastro doctor again.
Thank you and everyone else that responded to this question as it has been very very helpful to hear from you all!!!
Hugs to the support group people!
AquariusAnneCA
Reflux is most often from low stomach acid, not high. Treating it with antacids exacerbates it. When the stomach gets too low on acid from poor diet and/or meds, etc, it tries to compensate by squirting out excess acid which churns in the stomach (can cause bloating and discomfort). But this doesn't restore acid balance. It creates havoc for a while in a stomach that's too alkaline. Then that excess acid starts backing up into the esophagus, throat, etc. Using proton pump inhibitors or antacids stop the initial action of the excess acid and offer temporary relief. But it doesn't change the balance of pH in the stomach, and so to compensate for low stomach acid, it starts squirting out excess amounts of acid again, and the cycle is on. This is a slow, progressive process that can 'feel' like it's under control for some time but it's an unending cycle until you restore healthy pH in your stomach.
That will require some oversight and most likely a naturopath to do it correctly. Our usual medical professionals are wonderful people (I've worked for them for over 20 years and they can be expert in what they do, but they're trained to treat
symptoms. There are exceptions of those who go beyond their training to learn more, but most are doing the best they can with what they've been taught. So I encourage you to check into this. The naturopath can test you for this and guide you back to a well balanced stomach.
Also helping me tremendously is taking Braggs apple cider vinegar, which is organic raw unfiltered apple cider vinegar with the 'mother' in it. It has helped me tremendously. It sounds nuts but research it. It has improved the reflux symptoms, I sleep better at night, feel more calm. It doesn't interfere with any drugs. This helped get me through a severe attack, even though I was really hesitant to try it. I'm SO glad I did. So many other benefits, I'm going to stay on it. Hope this helps you and gives you new avenues to consider. Blessings!
I've been taking Omeprazole for 18 years, after having procedure to stretch back the scar tissue from my esophagus. From time to time I try Zantac because one Omeprazole side effect is weight gain. When I take Zantac, I have very strange, disturbing nightmares, causing anxiety. I hate that. Now I'm thinking of taking Nexium to see how it will work. Any thoughts on this? Anybody? Thanks.
I have been taking proton pump inhibitors for 13 years. I have had the Nissen Fundolpication surgery twice. Since my surgeries I have never been able to NOT take a PPI in the morning and one at night. I am just letting you know that both doctors (two different ones in two different hospitals) swore they would fix my problem with surgery. It's still not fixed and my goal was to get off the meds because of the long term warning that says if you take PPI's over 5 years plus double up doses like what I am taking causes early onset of osteoporosis. I have Barrett's esophagus. I am letting you all know that even though the doctors say they can cure you it's not a cure nor is it a long term fix. If you have a successful surgery you will most probably have to have it done in 10 years time. FYI
I take Ranitadine twice a day & have for about 30 yrs. Once in awhile I wake up from a sound sleep, not able to breath. for seconds & it is very scary. Learned years ago that most people think there is too much acid in their stomach but in actuality it is because there is not enough. All you have to do is take a spoonful of vinegar & it will immediately go away. The taste is not that bad & the desired result is well worth a few seconds of the taste.
In my case, Zantac and other similar meds did not work. They did neutralize the stomach acid temporarily, but the acid would rebound with a vengeance a little later. The acid burned the lower part of my esophagus, creating scar tissue. The scar tissue built up until the passageway narrowed to the point that food could not pass through to the stomach. I had to have it surgically enlarged by breaking apart the scar tissue. This had to be done 3 times before my doctor put me on Omeprasole in the early 90's. I've had no known side effects from taking it in all these years. The cost of the prescription has not been a factor for me either since my insurance only charges $3.00 per generic prescription.
I'm so sorry to hear this. You've been through a lot. take care---
FYI: if you are covered by Medicare part D these are available by prescription and less costly. If you itemize med expenses on US taxes, only prescription amounts/co-pays can be used.
I, too, have better results with Zantac which is also called ranitidine.
EndlessPred
thanks for the heads up on part d covering it for I was on protonix at one point but i don't think that is in my pharmacy formulary so i have to see if zantac is for this prilosec, I don't even no why I am taking it I am calling doctor today for the 10 th time and this x there is going to be yelling only I will be doing it for I keep telling them to dc it cause the pharmacy my mh deals with wont dc a med unless they get a faxed script saying dc prilosec on it, and idiots haven't done it after numerous times I have told them It don't work... I just got to call my scription plan and find out what is covered... thanks for heads up...
Angels yell? You will get more success if you are stern and threaten to report him for his lack of follow through. But be careful. Sometimes they give this to a nurse who isn't doing the job right and the doctor may be frustrated too. Tread softly but carry a big stick! Lol. Hope it goes well. Karen
zantac is on the Medicare pharmacy formulary.
very well said,Meyati! I was on omeprazol, but the prescription was too expensive. that's when I was told the OTC Zantac was better for me. Hopefully the advice you received will help you work out the problems you are having. I wish you luck in finding a resolution. Best wishes for better health.
Seeking peace,
Tee
Omeprazole-Prilosec stops the stomach from creating stomach acid. It can create a dry mouth and constipate. It dehydrated me so much in 3 days that i was in the ER with blown veins. Many people do quite well with it. I'm one of many people that prefer Zantac, It neutralizes the stomach acid. My doctor prefers to say that my body reacts better with zantac. Try taking a Zantac in the evening too, so you get relief in the evening. The rising stomach acid could cause you to be short of breath. What does your doctor say about this? Good luck
Hi to all of you and particularly Meyati since you answered another question I had and that was if I could/can/should take another in the evening! Only one problem... I did take one in the evening the other nite and I woke up with the same side affect which is a hiccuping feeling which I had with the Omeprazole... I do not want the Zantac to stop any acids which is what you all seem to say it will not do, since I ended up in the hospital sometime ago with a breathing problem and doctors not knowing why. CT Scan showed my lungs were like shattered glass! All kinds of tests taken and sent to John Hopkins with negative for any kind of allergy... I was on prednisone for a year...
I finally felt on my own it was the medication, "O" that was causing me so many problems and went off of it and Volla! all my problems stopped and a new CT Scan a month ago shows clear lungs! Doctor's (both lung and gastro) say they cannot and do not know if the "O" medication was giving me the problems. Want me to go for the fundiplication (sp?) but I decided on the Zantac after reading this support group... I will try the Zantac in the evening again to see if it gives me any former symptoms. I do get the heartburn in the evening again but try to just overcome it with drinking water and sucking on hard candy but would like to overcome the heartburn from happening. Thanks a bunch for all of your answers. I find this support group as a wonderful resource for answers to my problems. Have a wonderful day!
AquariusAnneCA
Hi Meyati... my primary doctor says see a gastro doctor, the gastro doctor says if I am having side affects, then have the surgery done... do not want to go for surgery if Zantac will help. I weaned myself from the Omeprazole and have learned not to eat before bed time and also to stay away from certain foods and I am doing so well except for the evening when the acid seems to develop... mainly when I lay down to relax...
Thanks so much for all your help...
AquariusAnneCA
I understand about the hiccuping--I did that a lot, and do it since my mouth was made smaller. What helps me is to drink more water during the day, and before I go to bed. I think that a person needs extra water with zantac. Then I forget, and I start hiccuping again.
What are "lungs like shattered glass?" That is not helpful. If your lungs were like shattered glass, would that not make them completely nonfunctional. What did you mean by this, and what possible connection is there between the issue at hand, the shattered glass lungs, and their miraculous recovery from ??? Thank you.
I just wanted to mention to folks that sleeping on your left side is better than sleeping on your right side when you have GERD. It has to do with your digestive system and gravity. If I sleep on my right side - instant GERD. Maybe you were told this by your doctor but I had to find out for myself!
Related topics
prilosec, zantac, helicobacter pylori infection, urinary tract infection, infections, pain, sinusitis, omeprazole, gerd, generic, sinus, bones
Further information
Similar questions
Search for questions
Still looking for answers? Try searching for what you seek or ask your own question.