Skip to Content

Whether to Preserve Fertility Is Tough Decision for Transgender Youth

THURSDAY, April 18, 2019 -- For transgender teens and young adults, deciding whether to freeze their sperm or eggs in case they want children later on is a complex decision.

A transgender person is one whose gender at birth does not match the gender they identify with. In the past, trangender adults would transition with surgery and hormones. Now, new medical directions are allowing adolescents to take hormones to transition, and suppress their fertility, at earlier ages.

"As a child psychologist, I'm usually talking to adolescent patients about contraception to prevent unwanted pregnancies, not, 'Down the line, do you want to be a parent? And if so, how important to you is a genetic connection to your child?'," said Diane Chen. She's an assistant professor of psychiatry, behavioral sciences and pediatrics at Northwestern University's Feinberg School of Medicine in Chicago.

Chen is also first author of a revealing new study examining the considerations that go into that decision.

For the study, her team interviewed 18 transitioning transgender patients, aged 15 to 24, about the factors that go into a decision on fertility preservation.

Key factors included: their family values, such as a parent encouraging or pressuring them to consider freezing their eggs or sperm; knowing whether they want biological children; cost of the procedure and storage; and concern about worsening conflict between their physical and emotional gender if they delay hormone therapy or undergo an invasive procedure to preserve fertility.

The findings provide insight into how difficult this decision can be and show the need for standardized protocols for primary care doctors counseling patients who are considering sex reassignment, according to authors of the study published April 15 in the journal LGBT Health.

"It can be difficult for kids who are transitioning in adolescence to have to be thinking about these things. It's not developmentally typical," Chen noted in a Northwestern news release.

Fertility preservation only recently became an option for transgender youth, and it can be difficult and ethically complex for doctors.

"Potentially compromised fertility should not be a reason to prevent transgender adolescents from transitioning with hormones, but we should be taking steps to train doctors on how to talk to transgender youth about options … and support them in making these decisions," Chen said.

Referring some patients to see a specialized fertility counselor for support might be a good idea, Chen suggested.

But even specialists might need to revamp their protocols. One study participant said reliable information can be lacking.

"I do kind of regret not doing the fertility [preservation] thing," said one 18-year-old in the news release. The teen received counseling but did not pursue fertility preservation. "I just wish they had told me, 'hey, there is a way, even after you start testosterone to do [fertility preservation]."

© 2020 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

Posted: April 2019

Read this next

Odds of Pregnancy in IVF Same With Frozen or Fresh Embryos: Study

FRIDAY, Aug. 7, 2020 -- Whether a frozen or fresh embryo is transferred during fertility treatments, the odds of pregnancy are roughly the same, according to a new Danish study...

A New 'Spin' on How Sperm Swim

FRIDAY, July 31, 2020 -- If you ever had a sex-ed class in school, you have probably seen a visual of sperm swimming with a wagging tail. Now, high-tech tools have shattered that...

What's the Best 'Uterine-Sparing' Treatment for Fibroids?

WEDNESDAY, July 29, 2020 -- Two "uterine-sparing" treatments for fibroids can improve women's quality of life -- though one might be more effective than the other, a new clinical...