Skip to Content

'Watchful Waiting' Less Likely for Black Prostate Cancer Patients

WEDNESDAY, May 22, 2019 -- "Watchful waiting" is on the rise overall among U.S. men with low-risk prostate cancer, but black men remain less likely to opt for it, a new study finds.

For the study, researchers examined 2010-2015 data on more than 50,000 low-risk prostate cancer patients in the United States. The investigators found that black men were 16% less likely than other men to decide on watchful waiting (also called active surveillance), instead of immediate treatment with surgery or radiation.

During that time period, surgery to remove the prostate gland fell from just over 41% to 29%, and radiation therapy fell from 46% to nearly 35% among black men. Among other prostate patients, rates of surgery fell from 48.5% to 31%, and rates of radiation therapy fell from about 37% to 25%.

In addition, rates of watchful waiting nearly tripled, rising from about 13% to 36% among black men, and from 15% to 43% among other men, according to the findings outlined in a letter in the May 22 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

Socioeconomic and insurance factors may be among the reasons why watchful waiting remains lower among black men, according to study co-author Dr. Brandon Mahal, of the Dana-Farber/Brigham and Women's Cancer Center, in Boston.

For example, poorer or less well-insured black men might have less access to the follow-up care -- periodic exams, blood tests and repeat biopsies -- required in active surveillance, Mahal suggested.

Another possible reason is that doctors may be concerned that low-risk prostate cancer is more aggressive in black men, he added.

Mahal said that several studies have suggested that black men with low-risk disease might have poorer outcomes than other men.

"Given the under-representation of black patients in clinical trials and concern about underlying aggressive disease, expert panels advise caution when applying conservative management to black patients," the study authors noted.

That awareness could persuade more black men to have immediate surgery or radiation therapy, Mahal said in a Dana-Farber news release.

The report "really demonstrates that there's a need for further study into low-risk disease in African American men so that we can better treat these men with low-risk disease," Mahal added.

Specifically, "we need clinical trials of African American men with low-risk prostate cancer where we evaluate their tumors for aggressive markers and also evaluate their outcomes with active surveillance. These studies would settle debates about the aggressiveness of low-risk prostate cancer in African American men and would help guide management decisions, which are now being made based on limited data," Mahal concluded.

© 2020 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

Posted: May 2019

Read this next

Big Babies May Face Higher Lifelong A-Fib Risk

MONDAY, Oct. 19, 2020 -- Parents are usually pleased when their newborn seems big and strong, but new research suggests that large babies may be at higher risk for the heart...

Your Pooch's Personality Can Change With Age

FRIDAY, Oct. 16, 2020 -- Just like people, dogs' personalities change as they age, a new European study suggests. "Even though dog personality is a highly popular topic in the...

More Prostate Cancers Are Being Diagnosed at a Later Stage

FRIDAY, Oct. 16, 2020 -- While men can take solace in a new government report that shows prostate cancer cases have been declining overall in the past two decades, the same...