Skip to Content

Lung Cancer Screening's Downside Not Discussed Enough

MONDAY, Aug. 13, 2018 -- The potential risks of lung cancer screening are often left out when doctors and patients discuss the issue, a new report suggests.

Early detection of lung cancer can save lives, and lung cancer screening is recommended for high-risk current and former smokers. But the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and other organizations say that doctors need to explain the risks as well as the benefits to patients.

Those risks include a high rate of false positives, which can lead to unnecessary follow-up procedures. And in some cases, screening can reveal lung cancer that, left untreated, would not have affected patients in their lifetime, the study authors said.

In this study, researchers analyzed 14 recordings of doctors and patients discussing lung cancer screening. On average, the talks lasted less than a minute, the quality of the conversations was poor, and discussion about the potential harms of screening was "virtually nonexistent," the investigators found.

"We're not taking a side as to whether lung cancer screening is good or bad, but there seems to be a consensus that we should be sharing these complex decisions with patients," said study senior author Dr. Daniel Reuland.

"Our fly-on-the-wall sample from real-world practice shows us that's not happening," he added. Reuland is director of the Carolina Cancer Screening Initiative at the UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center in Chapel Hill.

"A lot of people [with positive screening results] undergo surveillance, additional scanning, and some people undergo invasive procedures who don't have lung cancer," Reuland said in a University of North Carolina news release.

"The problem is weighing a small chance of benefit in the form of prolonged life versus a larger chance that a given patient will incur some kind of physical or psychological harm, plus out-of-pocket costs. It's important to talk about those potential harms and benefits with patients when deciding about screening," he suggested.

The findings were published Aug. 13 in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine.

The U.S. Preventative Services Task Force recommends annual lung cancer screening using low-dose computed tomography (CT) for adults 55 to 80 years old who have been heavy smokers.

© 2020 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

Posted: August 2018

Read this next

Will Expelled Droplets Spread COVID? Ventilation May Be Key

TUESDAY, Oct. 27, 2020 -- The tiny droplets that linger in the air after people talk, cough or sneeze aren't very efficient at spreading the new coronavirus, new research...

Patients With Worst COVID-19 May Be Best Plasma Donors: Study

TUESDAY, Oct. 27, 2020 -- Factors such as sex, age and severity of the disease may help identify COVID-19 survivors who have high levels of antibodies that can protect against the...

Trial of Antibody Drug for COVID-19 Stopped for Lack of Effectivenes

TUESDAY, Oct. 27, 2020 -- Testing of Eli Lilly's antibody drug for hospitalized COVID-19 patients has been halted because the treatment doesn't help them recover from their...