Verilogue Study of More Than 20,000 Real-Life Patient-Physician Interactions Reveals Patients' Top Health-Related Fears

New Verilogue Point-of-Practice Report Finds One in Four Doctor's Visits Include Fear Discussions;

Uncovers Variations in Physician Response

HORSHAM, Pa.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Jul 8, 2009 - Issues such as swine flu, peanut butter and cookie batter recalls and rising drug costs have recently inundated the air waves, blogosphere and Twitter updates – giving people plenty to worry about when it comes to their health. But a new study issued today by Verilogue explores the actual fears and concerns patients most frequently discuss in their doctors' offices – and just as importantly, how doctors respond to them.

Tweet this: @Verilogue news: Study of real-life patient-physician interactions reveals top patient fears http://bit.ly/gvteG

The review of 23,923 naturally-occurring patient-doctor interactions across 14 specialties over the past 18 months found that one of every four physician office visits includes a discussion about a patient fear. Key findings include:

  • Fear conversations arose around three main themes: diseases/illnesses, medicine side effects and life/social concerns;
  • Fear discussions are most likely to occur in psychiatric, cardiologist and neurologist visits and least likely to occur in pediatric, allergist and dermatology visits;
  • Primary care physicians tend to be less responsive to and empathetic with patient fears, likely due to the time demands of their practices on average;
  • Males and females were equally as likely to initiate a fear discussion with their physician;
  • Patients in their 20s are “fearless,” with the least number of fear discussions across age groups.
Specialty Fear Discussion
Psychiatrist 35%
Cardiologist 32%
Neurologist 31%
Pediatrician 29%
Oncologist 25%
Endocrinologist 25%
OB/GYN 25%
Rheumatologists 24%
Gastroenterologist 24%
Primary Care 23%
Urologist 22%
Allergist 17%
Dermatologist 15%

“Accessing and analyzing the naturally-occurring dialogue between patients and physicians is the only way to truly understand how physicians respond to what patients are thinking and saying, which, in today's consumer-driven health care environment, is more critical than ever,” said Jeff Kozloff, CEO and co-founder of Verilogue. “This analysis is just one in our series of Point-of-Practice studies that show how analyzing real-life patient-physician dialogue empowers all constituencies across the health care chain – pharmaceutical and health care companies as well as practitioners will better understand how to shape their conversations with patients so that information is made more relevant and personalized to unique patient situations and needs, which ultimately leads to improved health care practices and, most importantly, long-term health outcomes.”

Better Bedside Manner: PCPs vs. Psychiatrists

Verilogue's data and analysis revealed not only a varying degree of discussion of fears driven by the patient, but also a swing in the type of response these concerns generated from physicians. The most common PCP response was to simply acknowledge the fear statement with a quick “Okay” or “I know,” and move on without ever directly confronting the fear or asking for further elaboration. Data showed extremely limited examples in which a PCP directly engaged a patient's fear. In most cases, it was common practice for PCPs to not address patients' concerns, even when fears like “I'm so scared” were repeated.

On the other hand, psychiatrists, which represented the largest category of fear-based discussions, often responded like PCPs with a simple “Okay” or “Right” and then moved on, but unlike PCPs, psychiatrists commonly showed empathy toward patient fears, such as with “Wow. That's hard,” or “I'm glad he didn't do that.” Psychiatrists were likely to mention the word fear, even though they didn't necessarily ask for further elaboration from the patient regarding that fear.

Enemy Number One: Treatment Side Effects

While the number of conversations around disease/illness and life/social fears fluctuated across therapeutic categories, the level of concerns expressed about medicine side effects remained constant, accounting for approximately 20 percent of all fears expressed by patients during visits with PCPs and/or psychiatrists.

  • Medicine side effects – Generalized fears about taking medications were the most common type of fear expressed by patients in this category, as evident in the following authentic patient statements to their physicians: “I'm scared to take something. Everything has a side effect,” and, “I'm so scared. I'm allergic to so many medications.”
  • Diseases/illnesses – Encompasses statements such as, “My leg bothers me so much now” and “I'm scared to death of the test.” Depression, bipolar disorder and ADHD were the three most common disorders associated with a fear statement.
  • Life/social concerns – From financial woes to relationship issues to life planning, patients shared a wide variety of fears related to their lives outside of the clinical context. For example, “It's more pressing now that I don't have a roommate, and I'm worried about money.”

Methodology: Verilogue's Point-of-Practice Database

This is the first in a series of studies to be released by Verilogue that will reveal key insights into the patient-physician interaction, derived from Verilogue's Point-of-Practice Database which consists of more than 30,000 unique physician-patient conversations.

Working with 600 physicians across 50+ therapeutic categories, Verilogue recruits geographically diverse panels of high-prescribing physicians who see a large volume of patients, spend the majority of time in direct patient care and maintain a variety of practice types and/or locations. To gather data, physicians digitally record conversations with a few patients each month, following a double opt-in and HIPAA-compliant research protocol. Along with the recording, physicians provide patient chart information and attitudinal data around the interaction. From this database, Verilogue uses a combination of computer-based analysis and analysis from its team of linguists, statisticians and marketing experts to deliver insights.

For this study, Verilogue examined explicit statements of prominent fears and concerns shared by patients with their physicians across 23,923 in-office physician-patient visits over the past 18 months. These fears and concerns were identified through lexical analyses of transcript data and were reviewed by experts in conversation analysis and interactional linguistics to generate findings and validate interpretations.

For more information about Verilogue's Top Fears study, visit http://www.verilogue.com/contact.php.

About Verilogue

Verilogue (www.verilogue.com) is the first health care market research company to uncover, analyze and deliver nationwide insights derived from naturally-occurring dialogue between patients and physicians. With its patent-pending Point-of-Practice™ database and technology system, which digitally records real-time conversations between patients and physicians, Verilogue is able to capture critical information at the point of care, while maintaining patient and physician confidentiality. The insights gathered from these conversations, analyzed by Verilogue's team of linguists, statisticians and marketing experts, enable pharmaceutical and health care companies to gain a deeper understanding of patient and physician perspectives, help shape conversations that affect health care decisions, identify the most effective methods and tools to reach patients and drive the development and improvement of new and existing treatments to ultimately improve patient care.

More than 25 pharmaceutical companies have partnered with Verilogue to gain actionable insights from its database containing 30,000+ unique physician-patient conversations and corresponding patient charts across 50+ therapeutic categories. Founded in 2006, Verilogue is a privately-held company headquartered in Horsham, PA.

Contact: Lois Paul & Partners
Susan McCarron, 781-782-5767
susan_mccarron@lpp.com

Posted: July 2009


View comments

Hide
(web4)