Panic and Chaos in Pharmacies As Greece Runs Low on Hundreds of Medicines
Multinational companies accused of cutting supply Low prices and unpaid state debts being blamed
From Guardian (UK) (February 28, 2013)
Greece is facing a serious shortage of medicines amid claims that pharmaceutical multinationals have halted shipments to the country because of the economic crisis and concerns that the drugs will be exported by middlemen because prices are higher in other European countries.
Hundreds of drugs are in short supply and the situation is getting worse, according to the Greek drug regulator. The government has drawn up a list of more than 50 pharmaceutical companies it accuses of halting or planning to halt supplies because of low prices in the country.
More than 200 medicinal products are affected, including treatments for arthritis, hepatitis C and hypertension, cholesterol-lowering agents, antipsychotics, antibiotics and anaesthetics.
Separately, it was announced on Tuesday that the Swiss Red Cross was slashing its supply of donor blood to Greece because it had not paid its bills on time.
Chemists in Athens describe chaotic scenes with customers going from pharmacy to pharmacy to look for prescription drugs that hospitals could no longer dispense. The government list includes Pfizer, Roche, Sanofi, GlaxoSmithKline and AstraZeneca. Pfizer, Roche and Sanofi all said a few products had been withheld. GSK and AstraZeneca denied the claims.
"Companies are ceasing these supplies because Greece is not profitable for them and they are worried that their products will be exported by traders to other richer countries through parallel trade as Greece has the lowest medicine prices in Europe," said Professor Yannis Tountas, the president of the Greek drug regulator, the National Organisation for Medicines.
The regulator has investigated 13 companies that have reduced supplies and has handed the names of eight to the ministry of health so they can be fined.
"I would say supplies are down by 90%," said Dimitris Karageorgiou, secretary general of the Panhellenic Pharmaceutical Association, which represents pharmacists. "The companies are ensuring that they come in dribs and drabs to avoid prosecution. Everyone is really frightened. Customers tell me they are afraid [about] losing access to medication altogether." He said many also worried insurance coverage would dry up.
"Around 300 drugs are in very short supply and they include innovative drugs, medications for cancer patients and people suffering from clinical depression," said Karageorgiou. "It’s a disgrace. The government is panic-stricken and the multinationals only think about themselves and the issue of parallel trade because wholesalers can legally sell them to other European nations at a higher price."
The Hellenic Association of Pharmaceutical Companies said the picture was more nuanced. Its president, Frouzis Konstantinos, said there were "probably a very few companies" that were not supplying the Greek market, and only for very specific products - "the reasons being a combination of Greece’s low medicine prices and unpaid debt by the state", he said.
In Athens and Thessaloniki, chemists are often overwhelmed by people trying to find life-saving drugs. Oscillating between fury and despair, the customers beseech pharmacists to hand over medications that they frequently do not have in stock. "Lines will form in the early morning or late at night when you’re on duty," said Karageorgiou, who is based in Thessaloniki. "And when the drugs aren’t available, which is often the case, people get very aggressive. I’m on duty tonight and know there will be screaming and shouting but in the circumstances I also understand. We have reached a tragic point."
Greece’s social insurance funds and hospitals owe pharmaceutical companies about euros 1.9bn (pounds 1.6bn).
Some companies admitted they were not supplying some medicines. According to the government list, Pfizer had not supplied or would not be supplying 16 medicines. A spokesperson disagreed with the total but confirmed four medicines - two leukaemia treatments, an analgesic and the epilepsy therapy Epanutin - had been withdrawn "because alternatives were available and because of the parallel trade [reselling] situation in the country".
Roche stressed it had not halted supplies of medicines to Greece, but said it had withheld supplies to public hospitals that owed the company euros 200m. Daniel Grotsky, a spokesman, said: "We are insisting that they [the public hospitals] fulfil their contracts and this is something we do in any country . . . We are withholding [medicines] until they meet their obligations."
Roche could not say how many hospitals were affected but said it was still supplying public hospitals with "critical medicines", which included treatments for HIV and transplantation. Grotsky said patients could still get their medicines through pharmacies.
Angeliki Angeli, spokeswoman for Sanofi Greece, said it was supplying public hospitals with medicines considered life-saving, unique or irreplaceable. "Non-unique products are supplied based on hospitals’ outstanding obligations and overdue status," she said. Non-unique products are medicines for which either a generic exists or a therapeutic alternative option is recommended.
She said most Sanofi medicines on the government list remained available on the market with the "exception of a couple of dosages/forms where alternatives exist".
GSK Greece said it had never halted the supply of any product in the Greek market. "This is a joint decision taken not only at local level but also at corporate level. Equally, GSK has maintained the uninterrupted supply [to] Greek public hospitals with all its products irrespective of the accumulated debts," the company said.
Vanessa Rhodes, of AstraZeneca, said the company had not halted any supplies. "Our priority is to ensure patients have access to the medicines they need. Furthermore, we have an emergency ‘direct-to-pharmacy’ supply system in place should pharmacies find themselves out of stock of any of our products."
Zeta Chatziantoniou, of Boehringer Ingelheim in Greece, stressed it "has not halted any medicine supplies in Greece in the retail sector and public sector". Novartis said it was not halting supplies.
The industry says many shortages are because of products being exported through parallel trade, and has urged the government to address set drug prices. Under EU trade rules, while a pharmaceutical company may sell a medicine to a wholesaler or pharmacist in Greece, the buyer can sell these medicines on to wholesalers in other countries for a higher price. "The government needs to correct these wrong prices to avoid a surge of exportation. Greece’s drug prices are 20% or more lower than the lowest prices in Europe," said Konstantinos, who is also the general manager of Novartis in Greece.
The industry wants the health ministry to use a basket of eurozone countries to calculate prices. At present, medicines are priced at below the average of the three lowest prices in 22 EU countries.
The regulator has introduced export bans for nearly 60 medicines and is looking at 300 more products. It is also investigating 10 wholesalers and 260 pharmacists who it believes have broken the export ban. The ministry of health will decide any punishment, likely to be fines ranging from euros 2,000 to euros 20,000, said Tountas.
This month officials and Greece’s creditors must agree the 2013 pharmaceutical budget. More cuts would put patients at a "critical level", said Tountas.
Greek women outside a state health fund office in Athens. Patients have been going from pharmacy to pharmacy to find medicine Photograph: John Kolesidis/Reuters
Posted: February 2013